2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022  
Alfred DID NOT PARTICIPATE ----- Humanitarian Bowl: vs Florida A&M (W) Humanitarian Bowl: vs Colby (L) ----- ----- DID NOT PARTICIPATE DID NOT PARTICIPATE Alfred
                   
Anderson ----- DID NOT PARTICIPATE DID NOT PARTICIPATE DID NOT PARTICIPATE DID NOT PARTICIPATE DID NOT PARTICIPATE DID NOT PARTICIPATE DID NOT PARTICIPATE Anderson
                   
Arkansas Tech DID NOT PARTICIPATE ----- Emerald Bowl: vs Sacramento State (T) Aloha Bowl: vs Humboldt State (L) ----- ----- ----- Bluebonnet Bowl: vs Salisbury (W) Arkansas Tech
      Delta Conference Champion            
Bemidji State ----- ----- BCS: vs Kennesaw State (W), vs Pace (W) BCS: vs Rhode Island (W), vs Dartmouth (W) BCS: vs Salisbury (L) BCS: vs North Park (W), vs Florida A&M  (L) BCS: vs Kennesaw State (L) BCS: vs Morrisville State (W), vs Campbell (L) Bemidji State
        Kappa Conference Champion          
Campbell DID NOT PARTICIPATE BCS: vs Central Missouri (W*), vs Wesleyan (W*) ----- Emerald Bowl: vs Lafayette (W) ----- ----- Aloha Bowl: vs Princeton (L) BCS: vs Southern Illinois (W), vs Bemidji State (W) Campbell
                Power Conference Champion  
Central Missouri ----- BCS: vs Campbell (L*) ----- ----- Emerald Bowl: US Coast Guard (W) ----- ----- DID NOT PARTICIPATE Central Missouri
    Theta Conference Champion              
The Citadel DID NOT PARTICIPATE DID NOT PARTICIPATE DID NOT PARTICIPATE Peach Bowl: vs Indianapolis (W) Poinsettia Bowl: vs Limestone (T) ----- ----- ----- The Citadel
        Lambda Conference Champion          
Colby Emerald Bowl: vs Harvard (L) ----- BCS: vs Pace (L) Humanitarian Bowl: vs Alfred (W) Aloha Bowl: vs Southern Illinois (L) Poinsettia Bowl: vs Wisconsin Whitewater (L) Emerald Bowl: vs Dartmouth (L) Humanitarian Bowl: vs Youngstown State (W) Colby
            Sigma Conference Champion Sigma Conference Champion    
Cornell ----- ----- ----- ----- DID NOT PARTICIPATE DID NOT PARTICIPATE DID NOT PARTICIPATE DID NOT PARTICIPATE Cornell
                   
Dartmouth Humanitarian Bowl: vs North Park (L) Peach Bowl: vs Indianapolis (W) ----- BCS: vs Mount Union (W), vs Bemidji State (L) Humanitarian Bowl: vs North Dakota State (W) ----- Emerald Bowl: vs Colby (W) ----- Dartmouth
    Omega Conference Champion   Omega Conference Champion          
Florida A&M BCS: vs Whitewater (L) Aloha Bowl: vs Morrisville State (T) Humanitarian Bowl: vs Alfred (L) ----- ----- BCS: vs Kennesaw State (W), vs Bemidji State (W) ----- ----- Florida A&M
  Delta Conference Champion         Alpha Power Conference Champion      
Gallaudet DID NOT PARTICIPATE DID NOT PARTICIPATE ----- ----- ----- DID NOT PARTICIPATE ----- ----- Gallaudet
                   
Harvard Emerald Bowl: vs Colby (W) ----- DID NOT PARTICIPATE DID NOT PARTICIPATE DID NOT PARTICIPATE DID NOT PARTICIPATE DID NOT PARTICIPATE DID NOT PARTICIPATE Harvard
                   
Humboldt State Peach Bowl: vs Wesleyan (L) BCS: vs Wesleyan (L) Poinsettia Bowl: vs Rhode Island (W) Aloha Bowl: vs Arkansas Tech (W) ----- ----- ----- ----- Humboldt State
  Sigma Conference Champion Delta Conference Champion              
Illinois State DID NOT PARTICIPATE DID NOT PARTICIPATE DID NOT PARTICIPATE DID NOT PARTICIPATE ----- Copper Bowl: vs Kentucky Wesleyan (L) ----- ----- Illinois State
                   
Indianapolis ----- Peach Bowl: vs Dartmouth (L) ----- Peach Bowl: vs The Citadel (L) BCS: vs Whitewater (W), vs Salisbury (W) ----- Poinsettia Bowl: Kentucky Wesleyan (W) ----- Indianapolis
    Sigma Conference Champion   Sigma Conference Champion     Delta Conference Champion    
James Madison DID NO PARTICIPATE DID NOT PARTICIPATE DID NOT PARTICIPATE DID NOT PARTICIPATE DID NOT PARTICIPATE DID NOT PARTICIPATE DID NOT PARTICIPATE Copper Bowl: vs Kentucky Wesleyan (W) James Madison
                   
Kennesaw State ----- ----- BCS: vs Bemidji State (L) Poinsettia Bowl: vs Wesleyan (W) ----- BCS: vs Florida A&M (L) BCS: vs Bemidji St(W), vs Mount Union (L) ----- Kennesaw State
                   
Kentucky Wesleyan Peach Bowl: vs Humboldt State (W) BCS: vs Humboldt State (W), vs Campbell (L*) ----- Poinsettia Bowl: vs Kennesaw State (L) ----- Copper Bowl: vs Illinois State (W) Poinsettia Bowl: vs Indianapolis (L) Copper Bowl: vs James Madison (L) Kentucky Wesleyan
                   
Lafayette ----- Humanitarian Bowl: vs Notre Dame (W) ----- Emerald Bowl: vs Campbell (L) Peach Bowl: vs Mount Union (L) Humanitarian Bowl: vs Salisbury (L) ----- Aloha Bowl: vs Wisconsin Whitewater (L) Lafayette
        Delta Conference Champion Delta Conference Champion Delta Conference Champion      
Limestone DID NOT PARTICIPATE DID NOT PARTICIPATE DID NOT PARTICIPATE DID NOT PARTICIPATE Poinsettia Bowl: vs The Citadel (T) Emerald Bowl: Rhode Island (W) ----- ----- Limestone
            Omega Conference Champion      
Manchester DID NOT PARTICIPATE DID NOT PARTICIPATE ----- ----- ----- ----- ----- Pointsettia Bowl: vs Mount Union (W) Manchester
                Omega Conference Champion  
New Mexico Highlands DID NOT PARTICIPATE DID NOT PARTICIPATE DID NOT PARTICIPATE DID NOT PARTICIPATE DID NOT PARTICIPATE DID NOT PARTICIPATE DID NOT PARTICIPATE Emerald Bowl: vs Princeton (L) New Mexico Highlands
                   
Morrisville State ----- Aloha Bowl: vs Florida A&M (T) DID NOT PARTICIPATE ----- ----- ----- ----- BCS: vs Bemidji State (L) Morrisville State
                Sigma Conference Champion  
Mount Union BCS: vs Rhode Island (L) ----- ----- BCS: vs Dartmouth (L) Peach Bowl: vs Lafayette (W) Aloha Bowl: vs Notre Dame (W) BCS: vs Wisconsin WW (W), vs Kennesaw St (W) Poinsettia Bowl: vs Manchester (L) Mount Union
  Omega Conference Champion       Theta Conference Champion Theta Conference Champion Theta Conference Champion    
North Dakota State DID NOT PARTICIPATE DID NOT PARTICIPATE DID NOT PARTICIPATE ----- Humanitarian Bowl: Dartmouth (L) ----- ------ ----- North Dakota State
          Omega Conference Champion        
North Park Humanitarian Bowl: vs Dartmouth W) Emarld Bowl: vs Rhode Island (W) Peach Bowl: vs Salisbury (W) ----- -----G52-G53 BCS: vs Bemidji State (L) ----- ----- North Park
      Lambda Conference Champion            
Northern Arizona ----- ----- Aloha Bowl: vs Whitewater (T) DID NOT PARTICIPATE DID NOT PARTICIPATE DID NOT PARTICIPATE DID NOT PARTICIPATE DID NOT PARTICIPATE Northern Arizona
      Theta Conference Champion            
Notre Dame ----- Humanitarian Bowl: vs Lafayette (L) ----- ----- ----- Aloha Bowl: vs Mount Union (L) Humanitarinan Bowl: vs Youngstown St (L) ----- Notre Dame
    Kappa Conference Champion              
Pace DID NOT PARTICIPATE ----- BCS: vs Colby (W), vs Bemidji State (L) ----- DID NOT PARTICIPATE DID NOT PARTICIPATE DID NOT PARTICIPATE DID NOT PARTICIPATE Pace
      Kappa Conference Champion            
Princeton DID NOT PARTICIPATE DID NOT PARTICIPATE ----- ----- ----- ----- Aloha Bowl: vs Campbell W) Emerald Bowl: vs New Mexico Highlands (W) Princeton
                Theta Conference Champion  
Rhode Island BCS: vs Mount Union (W) vs Whitewater (L) Emerald Bowl: vs North Park (L) Poinsettia Bowl: vs Humbold State (L) BCS: vs Bemidji State (L) ----- Emerald Bowl: Limestone (L) Declined Bowl Game ----- Rhode Island
        Theta Conference Champion     Alpha Power Conference Champion    
Sacramento State DID NOT PARTICIPATE ----- Emerald Bowl: vs Arkansas Tech (T) ----- ----- DID NOT PARTICIPATE DID NOT PARTICIPATE ----- Sacramento State
      Omega Conference Champion            
Salisbury DID NOT PARTICIPATE ----- Peach Bowl: vs North Park (L) ----- BCS: vs Bemidji State (W), vs Indianapolis (L) Humanitarian Bowl: vs Lafayette (W) Copper Bowl: vs Southern Illinois (W) Bluebonnet Bowl: vs Arkansas Tech (L) Salisbury
      Sigma Conference Champion   Kappa Conference Champion        
South Dakota M&T DID NOT PARTICIPATE DID NOT PARTICIPATE DID NOT PARTICIPATE DID NOT PARTICIPATE DID NOT PARTICIPATE DID NOT PARTICIPATE ----- DID NOT PARTICIPATE South Dakota M&T
                   
Southern Illinois ----- ----- ----- ----- Aloha Bowl: vs Colby (W) ----- Copper Bowl: vs Salsibury (L) BCS: vs Campbell (L) Southern Illinois
                Delta Conference Champion  
US Coast Guard DID NOT PARTICIPATE DID NOT PARTICIPATE DID NOT PARTICIPATE ----- Emerald Bowl: Central Missouri (L) ----- ----- ----- US Coast Guard
          Sigma Conference Champion        
Wheaton DID NOT PARTICIPATE DID NOT PARTICIPATE DID NOT PARTICIPATE DID NOT PARTICIPATE DID NOT PARTICIPATE DID NOT PARTICIPATE DID NOT PARTICIPATE ----- Wheaton
                   
Wisconsin Whitewater BCS: vs Florida A&M (W), vs Rhode Island (W) ----- Aloha Bowl: vs Northern Arizona (T) ----- BCS: vs Indianapolis (L) Poinsettia Bowl: vs Colby (W) BCS: vs Mount Union (L) Aloha Bowl: vs Lafayette (W) Wisconsin Whitewater
  Theta Conference Champion       Alpha Power Conference        
Youngstown State DID NOT PARTICIPATE DID NOT PARTICIPATE DID NOT PARTICIPATE DID NOT PARTICIPATE DID NOT PARTICIPATE ----- Humanitarian Bowl: vs Notre Dame (W) Humanitarian Bowl: vs Colby (L) Youngstown State
              Omega Conference Champion