| 2015 | 2016 | 2017 | 2018 | 2019 | 2020 | ||
| Alfred | DNP | Humanitarian Bowl: vs Florida A&M (W) | Humanitarian Bowl: vs Colby (L) | Alfred | |||
| Arkansas Tech | DNP | Emerald Bowl: vs Sacramento State (T) | Aloha Bowl: vs Humboldt State (L) | Arkansas Tech | |||
| Delta Conference Champion | |||||||
| Bemidji State | BCS: vs Kennesaw State (W), vs Pace (W) | BCS: vs Rhode Island (W), vs Dartmouth (W) | BCS: vs Salisbury (L) | BCS: vs North Park (W), vs Florida A&M (L) | Bemidji State | ||
| Kappa Conference Champion | |||||||
| Campbell | DNP | BCS: vs Central Missouri (W*), vs Wesleyan (W*) | Emerald Bowl: vs Lafayette (W) | Campbell | |||
| Central Missouri | BCS: vs Campbell (L*) | Emerald Bowl: US Coast Guard (W) | Central Missouri | ||||
| Theta Conference Champion | |||||||
| The Citadel | DNP | DNP | DNP | Peach Bowl: vs Indianapolis (W) | Poinsettia Bowl: vs Limestone (T) | The Citadel | |
| Lambda Conference Champion | |||||||
| Colby | Emerald Bowl: vs Harvard (L) | BCS: vs Pace (L) | Humanitarian Bowl: vs Alfred (W) | Aloha Bowl: vs Southern Illinois (L) | Poinsettia Bowl: vs Wisconsin Whitewater (L) | Colby | |
| Sigma Conference Champion | |||||||
| Dartmouth | Humanitarian Bowl: vs North Park (L) | Peach Bowl: vs Indianapolis (W) | BCS: vs Mount Union (W), vs Bemidji State (L) | Humanitarian Bowl: vs North Dakota State (W) | Dartmouth | ||
| Omega Conference Champion | Omega Conference Champion | ||||||
| Florida A&M | BCS: vs Whitewater (L) | Aloha Bowl: vs Morrisville State (T) | Humanitarian Bowl: vs Alfred (L) | BCS: vs Kennesaw State (W), vs Bemidji State (W) | Florida A&M | ||
| Delta Conference Champion | Alpha Power Conference Champion | ||||||
| Harvard | Emerald Bowl: vs Colby (W) | DNP | DNP | DNP | DNP | Harvard | |
| Humboldt State | Peach Bowl: vs Wesleyan (L) | BCS: vs Wesleyan (L) | Poinsettia Bowl: vs Rhode Island (W) | Aloha Bowl: vs Arkansas Tech (W) | Humboldt State | ||
| Sigma Conference Champion | Delta Conference Champion | ||||||
| Illinois State | Copper Bowl: vs Kentucky Wesleyan (L) | Illinois State | |||||
| Indianapolis | Peach Bowl: vs Dartmouth (L) | Peach Bowl: vs The Citadel (L) | BCS: vs Whitewater (W), vs Salisbury (W) | Indianapolis | |||
| Sigma Conference Champion | Sigma Conference Champion | ||||||
| Kennesaw State | BCS: vs Bemidji State (L) | Poinsettia Bowl: vs Wesleyan (W) | BCS: vs Florida A&M (L) | Kennesaw State | |||
| Kentucky Wesleyan | Peach Bowl: vs Humboldt State (W) | BCS: vs Humboldt State (W), vs Campbell (L*) | Poinsettia Bowl: vs Kennesaw State (L) | Copper Bowl: vs Illinois State (W) | Kentucky Wesleyan | ||
| Lafayette | Humanitarian Bowl: vs Notre Dame (W) | Emerald Bowl: vs Campbell (L) | Peach Bowl: vs Mount Union (L) | Humanitarian Bowl: vs Salisbury (L) | Lafayette | ||
| Delta Conference Champion | Delta Conference Champion | Delta Conference Champion | |||||
| Limestone | DNP | DNP | DNP | DNP | Poinsettia Bowl: vs The Citadel (T) | Emerald Bowl: Rhode Island (W) | Limestone |
| Omega Conference Champion | |||||||
| Morrisville State | Aloha Bowl: vs Florida A&M (T) | DNP | Morrisville State | ||||
| Mount Union | BCS: vs Rhode Island (L) | BCS: vs Dartmouth (L) | Peach Bowl: vs Lafayette (W) | Aloha Bowl: vs Notre Dame (W) | Mount Union | ||
| Omega Conference Champion | Theta Conference Champion | Theta Conference Champion | |||||
| North Dakota State | DNP | DNP | DNP | Humanitarian Bowl: Dartmouth (L) | North Dakota State | ||
| Omega Conference Champion | |||||||
| North Park | Humanitarian Bowl: vs Dartmouth W) | Emarld Bowl: vs Rhode Island (W) | Peach Bowl: vs Salisbury (W) | BCS: vs Bemidji State (L) | North Park | ||
| Lambda Conference Champion | |||||||
| Northern Arizona | Aloha Bowl: vs Whitewater (T) | DNP | DNP | DNP | Northern Arizona | ||
| Theta Conference Champion | |||||||
| Notre Dame | Humanitarian Bowl: vs Lafayette (L) | Aloha Bowl: vs Mount Union (L) | Notre Dame | ||||
| Kappa Conference Champion | |||||||
| Pace | DNP | BCS: vs Colby (W), vs Bemidji State (L) | DNP | DNP | Pace | ||
| Kappa Conference Champion | |||||||
| Rhode Island | BCS: vs Mount Union (W) vs Whitewater (L) | Emerald Bowl: vs North Park (L) | Poinsettia Bowl: vs Humbold State (L) | BCS: vs Bemidji State (L) | Emerald Bowl: Limestone (L) | Rhode Island | |
| Theta Conference Champion | |||||||
| Sacramento State | DNP | Emerald Bowl: vs Arkansas Tech (T) | DNP | Sacramento State | |||
| Omega Conference Champion | |||||||
| Salisbury | DNP | Peach Bowl: vs North Park (L) | BCS: vs Bemidji State (W), vs Indianapolis (L) | Humanitarian Bowl: vs Lafayette (W) | Salisbury | ||
| Sigma Conference Champion | Kappa Conference Champion | ||||||
| Southern Illinois | Aloha Bowl: vs Colby (W) | Southern Illinois | |||||
| US Coast Guard | DNP | DNP | DNP | Emerald Bowl: Central Missouri (L) | US Coast Guard | ||
| Sigma Conference Champion | |||||||
| Wisconsin Whitewater | BCS: vs Florida A&M (W), vs Rhode Island (W) | Aloha Bowl: vs Northern Arizona (T) | BCS: vs Indianapolis (L) | Poinsettia Bowl: vs Colby (W) | Wisconsin Whitewater | ||
| Theta Conference Champion | Alpha Power Conference | ||||||
| Youngstown State | DNP | DNP | DNP | DNP | DNP | Youngstown State | |