 |
| Season | Champion | Owner | Runner-Up | League |
| 2022 | San Antonio Spider Monkeys | Scott Schmitt | Greensboro Evergreens | USFL |
| 2023 | Precott Valley Pulsar | John Krygier | Chesapeake Crustaceans | XFL |
| 2023 | San Antonio Spider Monkeys | Scott Schmitt | Hialeah Gargoyles | USFL |
| 2024 | San Antonio Spider Monkeys | Scott Schmitt | Spokane Dragonflies | UFL |
| 2025 | Spokane Dragonflies | Garrett Krygier | Fort Wayne Fusion | UFL |
| 2026 | Prescott Valley Pulsar | John Krygier Krygier | Fort Wayne Fusion | UFL |