| SCHOOL | SCHOOL | 1ST YEAR | CONTRACT | TROPHY |
| Arkansas Tech | Kennesaw State | 2022 | Thru 2027 | Honey Bee Bowl |
| Arkansas Tech | Southern Illinois | 2017 | Thru 2028 | Boot Heel Brawl |
| Campbell | Kentucky Wesleyan | 2017 | Thru 2028 | Kent-Bell Battle |
| Colby | Morrisville State | 2015-2016, 2020 | Thru 2025 | Pinstripe Prize |
| Dartmouth | Florida A&M | 2015 | Thru 2025 | Founders' Cup |
| Dartmouth | Rhode Island | 2015 | Thru 2025 | Battle for the Cap |
| Florida A&M | Kennesaw State | 2015 | Thru 2026 | Kelley & Hubbard Trophy |
| Humboldt State | Indianapolis | 2018 | Thru 2025 | 40 Degree Strife |
| Indianapolis | Manchester | 2018 | Thru 2025 | Hoosier Heartland Trophy |
| Jackson State | Notre Dame | 2025 | Thru 2026 | Colonial Cup |
| Kentucky Wesleyan | Manchester | 2019 | Thru 2026 | Ohio River Valley Hostilities |
| Limestone | Princeton | 2024 | Thru 2025 | Band-ten Hut Battle |
| North Park | UW-Whitewater | 2015 | Thru 2025 | Border Brawl |
| Notre Dame | Youngstown State | 2022 | Thru 2025 | Feather Frenzy |
| SCHOOL | SCHOOL | YEARS | RESULTS | TROPHY |
| Alfred | Princeton | 2018-2020 | Princeton 2-1 | Stein of Saxe-Coburg and Gotha |
| Alfred | Arkansas Tech | 2019-2020 | Arkansas Tech 2-0 | Gold Strife |
| Bemidji State | North Park | 2015-2023 | North Park 8-3 | The Big Muddy |
| Bemidji State | UW-Whitewater | 2016-2022 | Bemidji State 7-1 | St. Croix Clash |
| Campbell | Salisbury | 2019-2024 | Salisbury 4-2 | Sea-Camel Cup |
| Central Missouri | Lafayette | 2015-2019 | Lafayette 4-2 | Cy-Kry Cup |
| Central Missouri | Mount Union | 2015-2021 | Mount Union 8-2 | Purple Black Brawl |
| The Citadel | Rhode Island | 2019-2023 | Tied 2-2-1 | Sky Blue Skirmish |
| The Citadel | US Coast Guard | 2019-2023 | US Coast Guard 3-2 | Cadet Cup |
| Colby | Mount Union | 2015-2022 | Tied 4-4 | Original Six Trophy |
| Cornell | Kennesaw State | 2015-2018 | Cornel 4-0 | Salad Bowl Classic |
| Cornell | Rhode Island | 2016-2018 | Rhode Island 4-0 | Ram Red Rivalry |
| Harvard | Humboldt State | 2015-2016 | Tied 1-1 | H Cup |
| Harvard | Notre Dame | 2015-2016 | Tied 1-1 | Lambert Trophy |
| Humboldt State | Morrisville State | 2015-2016, 2020 | Tied 2-2 | Two Oceans Havoc |
| North Park | Lake Forest | 2024 | None | Northside Brawl |
| UK-Wesleyan | Southern Illinois | 2016-2017 | Tied 1-1 | Ohio Valley Cup |
| Lafayette | Notre Dame | 2015-2018 | Lafayette 4-1 | Jackson Memorial Trophy |
| Sacramento State | Salisbury | 2019 | Salisbury 1-0 | King James Crown |
| Southern Illinois | US Coast Guard | 2019-2023 | US Coast Guard 5-0 | Calumet Harbor Cup |